In the early afternoon of 26 November 2025, smoke began to curl around the façades of Wang Fuk Court in Tai Po. Within minutes, the green shroud of safety netting wrapped around the estate turned into a vertical wall of flame, running up and across seven of the eight residential towers. By the time the fire was finally declared extinguished at 10:18 on 28 November, at least 128 people were dead, dozens injured, and hundreds unaccounted for, in what is now Hong Kong’s deadliest fire since 1948.
Residents later described a strange silence inside the buildings: many never heard a fire alarm, relying instead on neighbours pounding on doors or frantic messages in chat groups. Investigators have since confirmed that none of the fire alarms in any of the eight towers activated properly during the blaze.
Outside, firefighters arrived within about ten minutes of the first 999 call, but faced a high-rise complex wrapped in burning scaffolding, flammable façade materials and intense heat that made entry nearly impossible for hours.
Very quickly, the images that travelled around the world all showed the same thing: flaming lattices of bamboo running up the towers like a burning cage. For many outside Hong Kong, the conclusion seemed obvious: bamboo scaffolding had turned a bad fire into a catastrophe. But the closer investigators and fire-science specialists look, the more the story becomes less about one material and more about a whole system that failed at multiple points, from the chemistry of façade materials to the way Hong Kong and mainland China now talk about each other when disaster strikes.

A city wrapped in a combustible system
Wang Fuk Court is not a luxury development: it is a government-subsidised Home Ownership Scheme estate from 1983, with eight thirty-one-storey towers and roughly 4,600 residents, about 40 per cent of them over 65.
A 2016 inspection mandated large-scale repairs, and by 2024 the owners’ corporation had approved a HK$330 million external renovation, carried out by Prestige Construction and Engineering. All eight towers were cocooned in bamboo scaffolding and green netting, and, crucially, the windows had been sealed with polystyrene boards for more than a year to keep dust out during the works.
On the day of the fire, Hong Kong was under a Red Fire Danger Warning; humidity hovered around 40–50 per cent and the winds were strong and dry: conditions in which any external fire will spread faster.
Residents had already complained months earlier about workers smoking and dropping cigarette butts on site, and a former security guard has claimed the fire alarm system had been intentionally turned off to make it easier for workers to move around.
While these specific allegations are still under investigation, authorities have confirmed a pattern of previous safety warnings to the contractor and deficiencies in fire-protection systems in the estate.
When flames finally appeared on the afternoon of 26 November, they did not begin inside a flat and slowly chew their way out. The first reports and video evidence show fire running up the external green netting that wrapped the bamboo scaffold on Block F, then jumping laterally and vertically to other towers, using the continuous “curtain” of mesh, tarpaulin, foam and bamboo as a three-dimensional pathway. Firefighters and officials have repeatedly highlighted this external route (not just the presence of bamboo by itself) as the key to the speed and scale of the disaster.

Bamboo on trial
To understand why bamboo has become the focus of so much anger and argument, it helps to remember what it represents in Hong Kong. For decades, bamboo scaffolding (light, flexible poles lashed together around glass and concrete towers) has been both a practical construction technology and a visual symbol of the city’s building culture. A 2003 study suggested around 90 per cent of scaffolding in Hong Kong was still bamboo-based at that time, long after mainland China had largely shifted to steel.
From a pure engineering perspective, bamboo has clear advantages: it is cheap, strong in tension, easy to carry through narrow streets and fast to erect. Fire-safety professionals in Hong Kong have long argued that bamboo scaffolding combined with genuinely flame-retardant nets and good housekeeping can be managed safely, emphasising that debris and poor site practices are often the main ignition sources in scaffold fires.
At the same time, both Hong Kong and mainland regulators have grown increasingly uneasy about its use on tall, occupied buildings, especially when wrapped in plastic mesh. In March 2025, authorities had already announced plans to phase out bamboo in favour of metal scaffolding for many projects; after the Wang Fuk Court fire, the Hong Kong government signalled a complete replacement, and Beijing launched a nationwide inspection of high-rise fire risks, explicitly listing bamboo scaffolding and flammable insulation as key targets.
International coverage of the Tai Po blaze quickly echoed this unease. Headlines from outlets in Europe, Asia and Australia described bamboo as “risky”, “flammable” and “a major factor” in the disaster, often pairing dramatic photos of burning poles with questions like why a “modern megacity” still relied on a “traditional” technique.
That framing resonated with many readers, but in Hong Kong it also struck a nerve: for some locals, it looked like an attempt to treat a familiar craft as backward and to reduce a complex chain of failures to a single, visually striking culprit.

What the fire science actually says
If we strip away emotion and politics for a moment, the fire-science picture is relatively clear. Bamboo is a lignocellulosic material (chemically similar to timber) and lab studies using cone calorimeters show that engineered bamboo products ignite at surface temperatures on the order of 350–400 °C, with heat-release rates and charring behaviour broadly comparable to wood.
Dry bamboo will burn vigorously once exposed to sustained heat and flame, forming a char layer that slows but does not stop combustion as long as the external heat flux remains high. In that narrow sense, the Hong Kong residents who grew up using dry bamboo to start stoves are not wrong: it is perfectly ordinary fuel.
However, in façade and scaffold fires, what matters most is usually which components ignite first and how they allow flames to spread, not just the presence of a combustible frame. Thin plastic or nylon meshes and bare foam insulation typically have much lower effective ignition energy than solid bamboo poles and can sustain very rapid flame spread once lit. In reconstructions and early official accounts of the Tai Po fire, investigators consistently point to the safety netting and polystyrene foam around windows as the first and fastest carriers of flame, creating a kind of vertical “chimney” between the scaffold and the wall that channelled hot gases upward and sideways around multiple towers.
From this perspective, bamboo’s role is twofold. It adds additional fuel once the fire is established, and it provides the skeleton that holds netting, foam residue, plastic sheeting and fallen debris together in a continuous, three-dimensional surface. Once the mesh and foam are burning along large swathes of the elevation, the heat flux at the scaffold can easily exceed the ignition threshold of the bamboo, causing poles to catch fire in many locations, drop burning pieces, and prolong the blaze. Fire-engineering analyses of the Wang Fuk Court incident therefore tend to describe bamboo as an important component in a coupled system: not the match that started the fire, and not the only accelerant, but a significant contributor to how far and how long the fire ran.

A chain of failures, not a single villain
The physical setting of Wang Fuk Court amplified this system. The estate’s towers are close together, forming a partial V-shape; when all eight are wrapped continuously in scaffold and mesh, the gaps between blocks become vertical channels where wind can drive flames and smoke. On the day of the fire, strong, dry monsoon winds and a Red Fire Danger Warning created exactly the conditions in which such an external fire would accelerate.
Inside the buildings, the usual defences of a high-rise (compartmentation between flats and alarm-driven evacuation) were weakened. Polystyrene boards that sealed windows at lift lobbies and elsewhere effectively punched combustible holes through the façade line; police now describe these as highly flammable and central to the way the fire moved from outside to inside.
Residents’ reports that alarms did not sound have since been confirmed by officials, and a former security guard alleges that systems were sometimes turned off for convenience.
Whether or not that specific practice occurred at the exact moment of ignition, the absence of functioning alarms clearly slowed residents’ reactions and forced firefighters to tell many people to shelter in place while they battled conditions too hot to allow safe entry.
In parallel, there is now a documented history of regulatory warning signals that did not translate into effective risk reduction. Labour and building authorities had inspected the site multiple times in the year before the fire, issuing warnings and even previous prosecutions to the contractor for safety breaches.
Yet at the moment of crisis, residents found themselves in a complex where flammable foam reportedly did not meet approved specifications, alarms failed, and a renovation design had effectively wrapped occupied elderly housing in a near-continuous external fuel layer. In that context, singling out bamboo scaffolding as “the” culprit understates the depth and breadth of the system failure that occurred.

Three narratives about one blaze
Beyond the chemistry and engineering, the Wang Fuk Court fire has also become a mirror for the fractured relationship between Hong Kong and mainland China. In mainland social media spaces, one prominent strand of commentary highlights bamboo as an outdated, unsafe practice that modern Hong Kong should abandon, often contrasting it with the mainland’s shift to steel scaffolding and stricter material rules. Weibo discussions frequently ask why a global financial hub is still “using bamboo,” and some posters explicitly frame the tragedy as proof that the city is less advanced than many imagine.
In Hong Kong forums, Telegram groups and Reddit communities, another strand pushes back hard. Many Hongkongers point out that bamboo scaffolding is widely treated to meet flame-retardant standards and argue that media emphasis on bamboo distracts from illegal or substandard foam, non-compliant netting and weak enforcement.
Some see the focus on bamboo as a way to avoid discussing governance: it is easier to blame a visible material tied to local culture than to confront inspection failures, cost-cutting in renovation contracts, or the decision to leave elderly residents living inside essentially shrink-wrapped towers.
Internationally, coverage often splits the difference. Outlets like Reuters, the BBC, Al Jazeera and others have all run stories on the “risks of bamboo scaffolding,” but most of their detailed reporting also notes flammable mesh, foam and alleged negligence by contractors.
The tension arises when headlines and social media clips emphasise bamboo almost exclusively, while the body text describes a multi-factor disaster. For audiences who mainly see the headline or a short video, that nuance is easily lost, and bamboo becomes, rhetorically at least, the main villain.

Why this touches Hong Kong–Mainland nerves
This divergence is not happening in a vacuum. Since the political upheavals of the 2010s and the tightening of Beijing’s control under the National Security Law, trust between many Hongkongers and mainland authorities has frayed. In that climate, how a disaster is framed carries political weight. When mainland state-linked outlets stress bamboo as the problem and highlight national-level action to ban it and tighten inspections, some Hong Kong commentators read this not only as a safety measure but also as an implicit message that Hong Kong’s distinctive practices need to be “corrected” by mainland standards.
Conversely, when Hong Kong voices insist that bamboo is being unfairly scapegoated, mainland readers sometimes interpret this as defensiveness or an unwillingness to modernise, especially given that large bamboo façades on occupied high-rises are already being scaled back in many other places for fire-safety reasons.
Identity politics enters quietly: for some Hongkongers, bamboo scaffolding is part of the city’s visual identity, a reminder of a time when local know-how and improvisation built skyscrapers without waiting for outside approval. For some mainland commentators, by contrast, the same bamboo stands for something old that should have been discarded once steel and stricter codes were available.
Underneath these perceptions, however, the factual record shows a more convergent reality. Both Hong Kong and Beijing have responded with investigations, arrests and pledges to tighten rules on flammable external materials and scaffolding.
Both sides officially acknowledge that bamboo, mesh and foam together formed a dangerous system, and both are moving toward metal scaffolding and stricter fire-retardant standards. The disagreement is less about whether change is needed and more about what, symbolically, is being blamed: a traditional craft, a set of materials, or the way safety is governed.

So, is bamboo really the culprit?
If we stay strictly with what can be supported by evidence from investigations and fire science, a balanced answer looks like this: bamboo scaffolding is not an inert or harmless bystander. Dry bamboo is a combustible structural material, and when used in full-height façades around occupied high-rises, it clearly increases the potential external fire load and the duration of a blaze once other materials have ignited.
In the Wang Fuk Court fire, the lattice of bamboo helped hold together a continuous fuel layer and likely contributed to the “fire-wall” effect that allowed flames to reach seven towers.
At the same time, the current evidence does not support the idea that bamboo alone “caused” the disaster. Early ignition and rapid flame spread appear to have involved plastic or nylon netting, flammable foam boards sealing windows, and perhaps other construction debris, all operating within a geometry that created a powerful chimney effect under dry, windy conditions.
These material choices were compounded by failures in alarm systems and by enforcement gaps despite earlier safety complaints and inspections. On that basis, most independent experts now describe bamboo as one strong link in a defective chain, not as the chain itself.
Seen this way, the lesson of Wang Fuk Court is less about condemning a single traditional material and more about how modern cities manage risk at the interfaces between old techniques, new products and stretched regulatory systems. Strongly restricting or phasing out full-height bamboo façades on occupied towers, strictly enforcing truly fire-retardant external nets and foams, and treating façade renovations as major fire-engineering projects rather than routine maintenance are all responses already being discussed or implemented by authorities and specialists.
None of these measures require choosing between “Hong Kong” and “the mainland,” or between tradition and modernity; they simply extend a basic scientific insight: in a complex system, tragedies almost never have a single culprit, and safety comes from understanding how all the pieces fit together before they catch fire.
Addendum: Meanwhile, in Mainland China, this subject is shadowbanned.



Leave a Reply